|
|
|
The "Mary Sue" argument is something I'd want to avoid entirely, especially since its actually meaning has been questionable from what I heard.
|
| |
|
|
I'm writing a looooong essay about it. Most people are idiots who just throw the term around and don't know what its meaning or origin is. In a nutshell, it's a term used to refer to a character that's unreasonably perfect for their given situation.
TV Tropes has an excellent article about it.
To give an example of what makes a Mary Sue a Mary Sue, I'll take a quick example from Marvel Comics, since they have a canon Mary Sue who's actually
intended to be that way, and I won't get any controversy for it.
Squirrel Girl is a Mary Sue. Everyone knows that. Why is she a Mary Sue? Because she can beat
anyone, including Thanos off panel. Her superpowers are all squirrel-based. The only reason that she could ever be so powerful is because of the fact that she's written as a canon Sue.
Galactus is another character from Marvel Comics who's absurdly powerful and could beat
almost anyone. Except, you know, Reed Richards. The reasons why he's not a Mary Sue character are pretty straightforward. He's given justifiable reasons for his strength, that being that he's one of Marvel's cosmic entities, and as mentioned, he does lose to lesser beings unusually often.
The term was really defined by the 70's Star Trek Fanfic "A Trekkie's Tale" in which Lt. Mary Sue, a 15-year-old Vulcan-human hybrid who Captain Kirk wants to sleep with. Spock takes an immediate liking to her, she receives the Nobel Peace Prize and several other similar awards, and after she dies a tragic death saving the Enterprise, her birthday becomes a holiday.
To list of the traits here wouldn't be too difficult. For starters, she's a lieutenant at the age of 15, which should be nigh-impossible, even with Vulcan heritage. Speaking of which, being a half-human hybrid is a common trait of a Mary Sue, and the fact that it mimics a canon character, Spock, makes it a trait to add to the pile. Kirk immediately hits on her as soon as the fic starts, despite her being 15. Now, it might just be that Kirk will have sex with anything that's alive and female, but the fact that she's 15 makes me question it.
Spock and Kirk both immediately liking her alludes to another trait, the fact that she's the center of attention in her fanfic. She also receives the Nobel Peace Prize, despite the fact that she's only 15, which is unreasonable. Sacrificing one's life isn't as common a Mary Sue trait as it is today, (probably because Mary Sues are often pet characters and Sue authors don't want to kill them off) but it does count. And lastly, her birthday becoming a holiday is just one more measure of absurdity.
Anyone one of those traits individually probably wouldn't have made for a Mary Sue, but piled together, you can see the horror beginning to emerge. Mary Sues are generally a collection of such traits, and often defy the general logic of their respective universe.
When writing fanfiction, it's often important to ask yourself if your character has too many traits that are common among fan characters so as to not be associated with Mary Sues. With Dragon Ball, I can tell you 95% of all fan characters are Saiyans who survived the destruction of planet Vegeta. Not all Saiyan characters are Mary Sues. I once read a fanfic with 6 of them, all of whom were actually good characters that made sense in context. They were supporting characters and the entire fanfic didn't revolve around them.